Legalizing Prostitution

Topics: Law, Decriminalization, Human trafficking Pages: 5 (1275 words) Published: October 5, 2013
Your Grade: 90.4 A-

Informative introduction to the topic, a controversial issue (worth 15%)87

~political or historical context
~facts or statistics
~examples or anecdotes
~quotations from authorities and experts

Informative introduction to two sources (web pages, articles, editorials, or essays) and their opposing positions on the issue (worth 20%)90

~two authors' names
~their professional affiliations or credentials
~titles of the two sources
~publication information
~each author's thesis

Analytical and constructive analysis of the opposing positions (worth 40%)88

~points of disagreement (values, moral principles, ideology, needs and interests, fears and concerns, priorities or agendas) ~points of agreement (over same, values etc.)
~suggestions for developing the conversation, building common ground, possibly striking a compromise

Fair and impartial presentation (worth 10%)100

~represent each side fairly and accurately
~be clear your purpose is to highlight and foster common ground ~don't judge either of the opposing positions
~give equal attention to both

Readable structure (worth 10%)95

~thesis and forecasting statement/s (saying that in the face of disagreement common ground exists) ~topic sentences for paragraphs
~consistent labels for the opposing positions (e.g. authors' last names) ~transitional words or phrases

Sentence-level issues (worth 5%)93

~following the guidelines on style, syntax, and punctuation that I've covered in PP presentations

Rulx Muller Malbranche
Nathanael Tagg
Eng. 101

Legalizing Prostitution
Considered as the world’s oldest job, prostitution has hunted society for ages. In some culture, it is seen as taboo, while in the United States the debate of legalizing it is prevailing. As a fact, prostitution cannot be put aside, something have to be done about it. Therefore, people from different background want to convey their point of view by any means possible. Some individuals come to say that prostitution should be legalized because it is a consensus between two people, and therefore, it should be respected. While others advance the principle of ethics, values and morals. In any case, this debate is in course, and prostitution on the other hand is still practiced, legalized or not.

In 2012, an article appeared in the New York Times magazine called “Legality brings protection and better care”. Chika Unigwe, PhD; the Nigerian-born author gives some of the reasons why prostitution should no longer be without law controls. She argues that where prostitution is illegal, women are more at risk of being violated by their customers, because they are by themselves; without help from any other. Cecilia Hoffman, Secretary of the Coalition against Trafficking in Women, wrote in 1997 a paper, “Sex: From Human Intimacy to Sexual Labor”. In this text she asserts that “prostitution violate the right to physical and moral integrity” and also “the right to liberty and security”; therefore, it should not be legalized. Admittedly, Unigwe and Hoffman seem to be on different sides of the question. However, both share a common ambition, which is to protect women in general.

Unigue states that, “criminalizing prostitution does not irradiate it…, it gives the customers in unfair advantage”. (Chika Unigwe, nytimes,com, April 19, 2012). From her point of view, the fact that we associate prostitution with crime and violence does not eliminate its existence. It reinforces the customers to take profit of the situation, knowing that it is a dirty game; therefore they should also play dirty. For Unigwe, legalizing prostitution will give women better advantages in this practice. Whereas Hoffman, who does not consider the advantages that would bring such legalization. She focuses instead in the consequences of prostitution in real life. She declares that “Prostitution violates the prohibition of slavery , of force labor and trafficking in...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Prostitution Essay
  • Prostitution Essay
  • Prostitution Essay
  • Prostitution Essay
  • Prostitution Essay
  • prostitution Essay
  • Prostitution Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free